All trusted press reviews plus, real audience thoughts.

James Phelan: Show Reviews

  • The Man Who Was Magic
  • Showman
  • The Dreamer
  • The Greatest Magician

Hundreds of ★★★★★ and ★★★★ press and audience reviews

James Phelan on stage
James Phelan leaving the judges speechless on Britain’s Got Talent

Accredited newspaper reviews

Word for word quotes from 39 published reviews, with links to read each one in full.

LondonTheatre1★★★★★

Show: James Phelan: The Man Who Was Magic (Five Stars)

“A confident and engaging performance, this is British magic at its finest, understated yet utterly magnificent from beginning to end.”

“a gentle style of humour combined with friendly banter made for a very entertaining evening”

Adelphi Theatre, London · September 2025 · Chris Omaweng

Read the full review of James Phelan: The Man Who Was Magic in LondonTheatre1 
One4Review★★★★★

Show: James Phelan: Showman (Five Stars)

“This “Showman” is a total natural and his show is one you won’t forget.”

“James has a wonderful stage presence, and the balance between trickery and humour is exceptional.”

Underbelly’s Circus Hub, Edinburgh · 25 August 2026 · Gavin

Read the full review of James Phelan: Showman in One4Review 
Scottish Field★★★★★

Show: James Phelan: Showman (Four Stars)

“Dazzling, old-school magic is back.”

“Whether you believe in magic or not, this is a fun-filled, extraordinarily impressive hour worth your time.”

Underbelly’s Circus Hub, Edinburgh · Edinburgh Fringe 2026 · Millie Pace

Read the full review of James Phelan: Showman in Scottish Field 
EdinburghGuide★★★★★

Show: James Phelan: Showman (Four Stars)

“He is instantly likeable, and clearly has a way with people.”

“leaves you laughing one minute and then leaning forward in your seat and whispering ‘how did he do that!?’ the next.”

Underbelly’s Circus Hub, Edinburgh · Edinburgh Fringe 2026 · Millie Pace

Read the full review of James Phelan: Showman in EdinburghGuide 
LondonTheatre1★★★★★

Show: James Phelan: Showman (Five Stars)

“clever, funny, surprising and bursting with personality! Highly recommended”

“the kind of magnetic, high-energy, theatrical experience that reminds you why live performance still has the power to astonish.”

Underbelly Boulevard, London · 21 June 2026 · John Groves

Read the full review of James Phelan: Showman in LondonTheatre1 
The List★★★★★

Show: James Phelan: The Dreamer (Four Stars)

“And what a joy it is to watch it executed so masterfully.”

“he’s certainly a spokesman for making the impossible possible.”

Underbelly’s Circus Hub, Edinburgh · 16 August 2024 · Kelly Apter

Read the full review of James Phelan: The Dreamer in The List 
One4Review★★★★★

Show: James Phelan: Troublemaker (Four Stars)

“this confident and yes highly talented young magician had stage presence by the bucket load”

“He is definitely an up and coming performer and I’m sure he will go far.”

Gilded Balloon, Edinburgh · 10 August 2019 · Geoff

Read the full review of James Phelan: Troublemaker in One4Review 

Quotes are taken word for word from each review. Star ratings are as published by each reviewer.

Facebook reviews

Comments left on James’ Facebook page, facebook.com/phelanmagician.

Screenshot of the Facebook comment from Heather Anne
Heather Anne: Last night's show in Yarm was brilliant! James, you had a great connection with the audience and weren't flawed by having to direct the lighting throughout the show. How on earth you managed some of those things (dont want to drop a spoiler!) I can't fathom. I would love to see a more equal split of male/female participants next time we see you 😀
Screenshot of the Facebook comment from Sonia Smith
Sonia Smith: Absolutely Amazing, Bolton Octagon, had a fantastic time , definitely recommending your show to everyone, thank you for bringing your magic, wit, charm and great personality to Bolton
Screenshot of the Facebook comment from Erwin Freeland
Erwin Freeland: The show was absolutely awesome.... First time witnessing this artistry in person and the show had such a meaningful message while entertaining us with whit and humour. Must see people!!!!! Sarah Miles Kylie Freeland Maureen Miles Ian Hawkes
Screenshot of the Facebook comment from Julia Westlake
Julia Westlake: We have seen you at Leeds City Varieties theatre and the intimate secret venue in Harrogate. Both phenomenal and a great night of entertainment. Always leave feeling like, how did he do that???!
Screenshot of the Facebook comment from Teresa Bentley Prev Spicer
Teresa Bentley Prev Spicer: I came to your Cobham Hilton show. It was absolutely amazing and so much fun to be such a big part of the act, with so few audience members. Would definitely try for front row tickets next time, as my son was desperate to be even more involved. 100% have recommended it to everyone.
Screenshot of the Facebook comment from Liz Wilsher
Liz Wilsher: Saw your performance in Sheffield last Friday...absolutely fantastic!!! No idea how you did what you did but thoroughly enjoyed it and would definitely book your next tour 10/10* !!
Screenshot of the Facebook comment from Sharon Johnson
Sharon Johnson: Saw you last night at redditch our first time seeing anything like this was amazing definitely recommend you to others and will come and see you again thanks for a great time x
Screenshot of the Facebook comment from Irene Rainbow
Irene Rainbow: Watching him now at Wyllyotts theatre. Amazing! unbelievable! Mesmerising are the only adjectives I can think of to describe him & his show!
Screenshot of the Facebook comment from Julia Simpson
Julia Simpson: Really enjoyable show in Epsom theatre last night. James is a very clever magician/hypnotist/mentalist. His engagement with the audience is honest and so amusing!For a guy with ADHD he manages the show completely and with humour. Well worth seeing! Lottery number 28 reporting..lol X
Screenshot of the Facebook comment from Scott Beaumont
Scott Beaumont: I came 3rd June this. My 46th birthday and my first ever being on my own. You saved my birthday. What a truly magical and mystifying show. Thank you
Screenshot of the Facebook comment from Rosie Gallagher
Rosie Gallagher: Me and my son have been twice and loved the show! He particularly enjoyed the VIP experience after the show. We are gutted there is no date for Stafford, do you know when you’ll be back here? 🥰
Screenshot of the Facebook comment from Sue Lynch
Sue Lynch: We came to the show at Stafford. Can honestly say it was extremely entertaining and we both really enjoyed it, the time flew past, always a good sign you are having fun x

Audience reviews

Filmed in the foyer straight after the show. Tap to play, with sound.

Instagram reviews

Comments left on @phelanmagician posts, shown word for word.

bougie_and_bijou_steep_hill Went to see James last night at the magic circle london.. got to say it was one of the best things I have seen in a long time.. funny, quick witted, and genuinely mind blowing... my partner was sat next to him at the table and was involved in many of the tricks, he has not stoped talking about it all day today.! Thanks James.!

judygemini Saw the show last night at the Delta Hotel in Peterborough. You blew our minds - simply brilliant. You are a great entertainer, love your natural chat and audience participation. We would definitely come and see you again. However, I was somewhat embarrassed about my Wiki Article Count failure 🤣

thetracyrobertson Saw you tonight at the Redgrave theatre Clifton Bristol. You were amazing made even more special as my best friend Nicky played a major part in your show tonight. We are now sat in my kitchen still looking at the glass you kindly signed and we still can’t believe what you did with her wedding ring. What a fan night we will be back x

chelsea_moore_92 Such an amazing show loved by all three of us 🪄 truly magical night at Havant, which bought awe to our faces and absolutely blew us away.. thank you @phelanmagician, and 2 out of 3 of us were involved and just couldnt believe how spot on you were 👏🪄❤️

lesleyannfleming22 We saw you last night at the Forum (don’t worry I’m not Julie)😂 We had the most amazing night and I’m still bemused today tbh. You are incredible, funny , and so clever at what you do and very entertaining, can’t wait to see another show in the future 👍🏼❤️

hkovari1 Have seen you perform a few times (in London) and always thoroughly enjoyed it.. I’ve always loved magic and love to be baffled.. it’s mesmerising. Saw the intimate show at Swindon Hilton which was excellent. Some of the audience were special. .. Hilarious.. 🤣

ro_se3682 We had a brilliant night. I love magic. My husband unsure. We both came away blown away. So clever. Loved being in the close intimate show at Hilton Cobham. Highly recommend you.

claire.2609 Saw you in Canterbury a couple of weeks ago... great show, lots of interaction and James was very quick witted & funny!! Magic was incredible...Would definitely go again...thanks for a great night!!

shoehornbill It was an excellent evening, intimate venue and felt a part of the show. How James remembers everyone's names as well as keeping on top of the show! Fabulous, would highly recommend. Thanks for a great evening

hellsdd Came to the show in Cobham last night. Initial preconception based purely on the poorly stocked small bar and the actual room was “um, how good will this be?” You absolutely blew our minds and we had the most superb evening! Spent the whole journey home going “but how did he do that?” Incredible work and we loved every minute! Husband has already looked to see where we can see you again!

nancymaysoprano Brilliant show. Really moved by the coin and aspiring for your dreams ✨ will recommend!!

themurrays001 We saw you at The Hilton , Swindon. You are amazing, funny , so talented , absolutely blew my mind ! A fabulous evening. Thank you

agolds2387 Great show. Don’t know how he done it but it was brilliant

sasha219s The BEST show I have ever seen, thanks @phelanmagician for making my first solo date simply unforgettable!

jimmydelpmagicshop Love hearing your parents were blown away! Glad you got to experience it live too 😁

debssthompss Went to the show in Tunbridge wells with my daughter and thoroughly enjoyed the show, very entertaining. James’ quick and witty banter with the audience was definitely a highlight and the magic was amazing. No idea how he does it. Would definitely recommend 😍.

sparkymarkexelby Went to the Harrogete show last night. Had a great time very entertaining.

delsobaby The fam and I saw you in Eastbourne in March, absolutely fantastic!! Totally fun evening and just watched you on BGT!! Awesome!!

cyclingrob3 Best night out for ages. James has such an easy charisma and his audience interaction is brilliant. I have no idea how any of the tricks were done!

mick_gauntlett Fabulous evening of magic....... highly entertaining and absolutely mind blowing. Loved it 😁😁😁

radlaura Absolutely incredible 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥 loved every moment rebooked for Tunbridge Wells 2027

jamieleonardmagic One of the best magic shows I saw at the fringe. Highly recommend! Have already booked tickets to see it again ❤️🙌🔥

alison.durant A brilliant and compelling show and great entertainment . James is sharp, funny and incredibly talented, leaving the audience constantly thinking - how did he do that!

kissmyaa Absolutely blown away by James’s phenomenal talent. Been lucky enough to see a few of his different productions. Whether it be a big theatre or an intimate venue, it’s always a treat.

grannyp2021 Fascinating!! Just seen you in Milton Keynes

agolds2387 Best show we had seen for ages

relax_kids Came to see the show in Oxford last night.... loved the fire, the coin, the ring, the glass, the chairs, the magic colour button, the surprises. Filled with Awe - awe is so good for the nervous system! Awesome and some.

ooky84 A phenomenal show that brings magic, humour and great banter. My Dad and I both left with a renewed sense of wonder and huge smiles. Awesome, James! We'll be back for more ❤️

wallis.marie We came to see you on Friday night at the Cobham Hilton. Amazing 🤩 I don’t know how you do it, pretty gobsmacking. Brilliant and entertaining, thank you 🙌🙌

lyra.langley Absolutely amazing 💙 my mum was so embarrassed but had an amazing time even though her ring was indeed stuck on the glass, would definitely 1000% go again x

sharonhobbs24 Seen him twice, so charismatic and funny, very clever shows!

melt.n.meld There was one small sleight of hand type trick I got, but everything else was just astounding! Husband and I had a great time at the show last night and left believing in magic 🤩

thekirstylmason We saw you thus evening at Wychwood Park 👏phenomenal 🙌

carlymellors Came to the Derby show and really enjoyed the smaller venue. Brought my children too and they loved it. Would recommend

sanguinegreen37 Fantastic show! Funny, and great entertainment!

waplev Just seen you in Milton Keynes, amazingly mind blowing- Fantastic show- will be booking for June show in London 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

mamamoomin222 Saw you last night in Bristol. Great show. Despite some difficult participants 😂 really enjoyed it.

mitchmitchell1882 Simply awesome 🪄✨ 🔥

paula_bakes1981 We saw you in Yarm and you were amazing. We have just watched you tonight on BGT and again you were amazing

mymagicalquests The show was phenomenal. I can't work out how he did it so it must be magic! Totally recommend it for all ages! 🌟🌟🌟🌟

nickijaneedwards Very intimate show - great showman ! Thoroughly enjoyed it.

susansheldon8335 Saw James for 4th time last night at Brierley Hill - amazing show, amazing bloke!

kate_victoria12 Great evening! Loved every minute.

paddydickr Saw you in MK what a great show,

martin.binnie The first time , i have been to see you, or been to that theatre, very impressed with the show, made me laugh, ,made me wonder how do you it, loved the atmosphere, had a great time 😀

tetchysteve Absolutely brilliant last night in Havant - best Magic show we have ever seen., and we have seen lots! Good luck in London, you will amaze them! 👏🙌

mamadarch We saw you at Edinburgh last summer and loved the show!

lisa.b.987 We absolutely loved it, saw you in Canterbury and totally blown away 👏👏👏👏👏

prit_13 James you were amazing! Kept the audience captivated all the time. Look forward to booking again

joworkman75 Absolutely gobsmacked throughout. Such good entertainment! We loved it 😊

ellenayinteriors Went to see James in Tunbridge wells in March with my Dad. We were sat in the front row so were quite involved in the show. Had a fabulous evening! James is very funny which, combined with great magic, made for a very entertaining evening. Would highly recommend. What a nice guy too 😊

tyanastuart I think you are an amazing magician! Handsome (bonus😍) and a people’s person who connects emotionally during your show. Your performances are jaw dropping!

phillg1970 Very entertaining and I couldn't tell how it was done!

silou_pip We went to Lincoln yesterday. Absolutely amazing performance with lots of humour too. It’s a must see show 🔥

magicstar44 Loved the show in Blackpool - worth a watch and the way you build audience rapport is unique. Would love to see a bigger show too - but then I love Magic 🪄 both real and unreal 👏

michalnunn Brilliant! Magic that defies logic and humour to go with it. A memorable night. Highly recommend! 🪄

luke.vee14 Went to see @phelanmagician All The Secrets I never Told show yesterday in Birmingham. Fantastic show once again. This was my second time seeing him after seeing him a few months ago for the Man Who Was Magic in Redditch. Great tricks, brilliant magic and excellent showmanship. Love his humour and the interaction with the audience. Will definitely book to see again if he has any other shows in the area.

jamesstephenbattle Easily, the best magic I have ever seen. Really mind blowing to work out how he does it.

abbgard I got tickets for my parents before to see your show and they were blown away. They told me if you do another one I need to go and see it. And I did. And wow! The show was amazing! I honestly don’t know how you do it 🤯 First time I’ve ever seen magic on stage and I’ll definitely be back to see another one of your shows. Thank you 😁

nmd_ward WOW!! Just seen you in Northamptonshire on a school night - what a fantastic show full of magic and comedy! Thank you 👏🏻😍

joec_rr_ Absolutely unbelievable. I will never know how you did it. You had me up a lot haha this evening and I loved it. I hope those numbers come in 🤞🤣

o_lga_f Incredible!!!

serendipity_house_kirkham We saw you at the Clifton Hotel in lytham this week - amazing 😍

mrs_s_mcguinness The best magic show I have ever seen! Enjoyed the intimate venue and involvement in the show. Thank you for a fab night!

rickdwright Went to the show in Lincoln by far the best night of entertainment I've ever had absolutely incredible show was left gobsmacked and I've been telling everyone about it! Mind blowing 🤯!

inchmarilyn Great performance my first magic show but certainly not my last will certainly book another show 👏😂

liz.bonham.9 Great evening!! First time at one of your shows in Milton Keynes. We were sat in the front row, right next to the table where we had an excellent view of your performances!! Very talented, we left not having a clue how any one of them was done!!! Very clever. Both my husband and myself took part in some of the “tricks”, and even being that close had no idea how James performed them!! Wld definitely recommend and wld certainly go to another of James’ shows. Very professional but kept us all entertained throughout. Great stage presence 👏 Liz

fiona.walkinshaw Was at The Harrogate Show last night , you were great , just booked to come to your Leeds show in November . I'll have to bring my glasses to that one though 😂🤣

leanne.smith.burchnell Amazing show! Some real woooowww moments! Would definitely watch again! 😍

louisehrycak I took my daughters to the show at Whittlebury and it was amazing. Apart from being really entertaining and fun the mind does boggle at how was any of that possible? Seeing James in Britain’s Got Talent felt like cheering on a friend, of course he did really well.

marksforster Attended a show in Harrogate last night. Was a Birthday present for my wife. We were blown away, what a fantastic night out. Thank you.

andyb.1968 Great show, venue and material

lindseym167 What a great evening. A really talented magician, very natural interaction with the audience and a thoroughly entertaining set. Thank you 👏

marty_sheff Saw Soho show last night was amazing all new material to past other shows ive seen - look forward to seeing you in Sheffield later in the year! Great theatre also never been there before.

scott.beaumont.1703 Absolutely brilliant, it has magic, hypnosis and is enthralling and funny throughout. Can’t recommend highly enough

breezyday189 Went to your show in Harrogate. Totally amazed, couldn't stop talking about how you managed to do all those tricks, and we were very close up to you!

lindsay.heasman It was a great show! Slight mix up with the booking but the team sorted it all out and we had a fab time! Back again to see it in a few weeks x

See him live, or learn the magic

Shows and books

Shows

James Phelan on stage in The Man Who Was Magic

Live show, touring now

The Man Who Was Magic

The five star show from the Adelphi Theatre in London’s West End, now touring theatres across the UK.

Book tickets
James Phelan with a microphone among the audience at The Secret Room

Intimate live show

The Secret Room

James’ intimate 100 seat show, in secret rooms in hotels around the country. 90 minutes.

Find your nearest date
James Phelan breathing fire on stage under blue light

New for 2027

The Impossible Man

A completely brand-new show for 2027, touring from autumn 2027. Age guidance 12+.

Dates announced soon
James Phelan: Showman posters on the brick front of Underbelly Boulevard Soho

Past show, 2026

Showman

A strictly limited summer season at Underbelly Boulevard Soho in London, then a run at the Edinburgh Fringe. Five star reviews in both cities.

Read the Showman reviews

Books

Cover of How to do Magic by James Phelan

Book

How to do Magic

Tricks, secrets and showmanship with things you already own. 124 tricks.

Get the book
Cover of The Eighty Greatest Card Tricks by James Phelan

Book

The Eighty Greatest Card Tricks

Eighty of the best classic card tricks, step by step. Free, you just pay the postage.

Get your copy

Magazine and podcast

Cover of Magicians Monthly, the magazine by James Phelan

Magazine

Magicians Monthly

James’ monthly magazine of magic secrets, posted to your door.

Find out more
How To Be Famous podcast artwork with James Phelan

Podcast

How To Be Famous

James’ podcast on YouTube, Spotify and Apple Podcasts. Guests include Katie Price, Gareth Gates and Melinda Messenger.

Watch on YouTube

Press releases

Internationally acclaimed magician continues unprecedented five-star tour

James Phelan, as seen on Britain's Got Talent, brings The Man Who Was Magic to theatres across the UK.

Read the press release (PDF) →

Forget the cracker joke: 124 tricks to steal the show this Christmas

Internationally renowned British magician James Phelan publishes new book: How to do Magic: Tricks, Secrets and Showmanship With Things You Already Own on 1 December 2026, with presales from 15 November.

Read the press release (PDF) →
Book ticketsLive shows touring the UK nowThe Man Who Was MagicThe Secret Room